"Guest" Post: Will And Ariel Durant On Democracy
As a form of government, the advantage democracy saliently presents over others is the facility to possibly promote those most able, regardless of caste, to positions of leadership by common approbation, achievement, and consent. If any system can figure out how to promote its most capable minds, its advantage will be potent.
In contrast to dictatorship or aristocracy, arrangements which guarantee the systemic promotion of hermetic stupidity, timidity, corruption, and neglect, democracy at least holds out a chance for meritocracy. It assumes fundamentally that intelligence and ability are not the provinces of class or heredity, but intangible, competitive qualities which are vastly improved by an equal access to knowledge. Dummies may live and struggle in democratic squalor, but their children, if they make their way smartly through the system, could be elected President or Prime Minister. As was Bill Clinton on his merits in the former United States, and John Major on his in the United Kingdom. Clinton was the illegitimate son of a cleaning woman and a traveling salesman, born and raised in a state best known for its obscurity. John Major dropped out of school at sixteen and was the son of a former vaudeville musician.
We live in a special time, in that more information flows to our fingertips more freely than ever before, just after the tireless cheerleaders of dictatorship seized upon electronic megaphones to lead the crowd in chants. But how does democracy, on the whole, compare to the Platonically cycling formulae of aristocracy and dictatorship?
All deductions having been made, democracy has done less harm, and more good, than any other form of government. It gave to human existence a zest and camaraderie that outweighed its pitfalls and defects. It gave to thought and science and enterprise the freedom essential to their operation and growth. It broke down the walls of privilege and class, and in each generation it raised up ability from every rank and place. Under its stimulus Athens and Rome became the most creative cities in history, and America in two centuries has provided abundance for an unprecedentedly large proportion of its population.The Lessons of History, pp. 78-79
Democracy has now dedicated itself resolutely to the maintenance of public health. If equality of education can be established, democracy will be real and justified. For this is the vital truth behind its catchwords: that though men cannot be equal, their access to education and opportunity can be made more nearly equal. The rights of man are not rights to office and power, but the rights of entry into every avenue that may nourish and test a man's fitness for office and power. A right is not a gift of God or nature but a privilege which it is good for the group that the individual should have.
Recent posts regarding democracy's drawbacks set me to searching for what some better thinkers on civilizations had to say. To a person who studies the classics at the expense of noticing modern surroundings, the word "democracy" will have a very different meaning to them than it does to the average person. To the Greeks and Romans, for example, democracy was an unfortunate aberration, a time between aristocracy and monarchy, and the word automatically calls up scenes of dreadful disorder and bloody vengeance. To us today, it is a representative-driven device for balancing and managing power, diluting, re-distilling, and applying it as carefully debated circumstances require.
The Durants note, along with their fellow traveler Arnold Toynbee, the main weakness of democracy as a system: its easy susceptibility to bribery. If they were alive, and had the chance to sit on my couch for some tea, I suspect they would quickly notice that there is a new kind of nation, ones which have surpassed borders. One example they might train their capable minds on would be Walmart, which currently comprises the fourth-largest economy in the world. I wonder what they would call it, and how they would describe its effects on the old systems of aristocracy, democracy, and dictatorship.
219 comments:
1 – 200 of 219 Newer› Newest»Even from the most vulgar managerial perspective, democracy is desirable -- assuming, of course, that feedback and audit trails mean anything to the managerial elite.
I think the desire for a political condition of answerable questions and real answers to them is not quite dead, but I'll be damned if I can figure out a way to make it mainstream.
Feedback? Audit trails? {Gulp.}
It's all stagecraft now. As soon as anybody dares make a true statement, they're hunted down like a fox, complete with the braying of horns and chasing hounds. Like with Dean and Obama.
When I re-read one of those lines above I think Rolling Stones magazine. You gotta read this one on how the Monster Bush people stole the US Treasury, then see if the folks you quote would likely turn over in their graves. Copy and Paste in Browser. Would love to read your comments Marclord!
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/story/16076312/the_great_iraq_swindle
Zoey's Human:
Thanks for the link. Glad you're out there still reading Rolling Stone for me! I'm into page 2 of the article, and it's already nailed what's going on. The Bush Administration combined the worst aspects of communism, capitalism, religion, and cronyism. Their market mechanism is The Naked Hand.
Marc,
Nothing could be more interesting at this time in American history than analyses of democracy because I think we're seeing an example of the ultimate corruption of the concept. Isn't it basically a defensive form anyway -- protection against kings, tyrants, and people whose only qualification for leadership is their parentage? Except for its value as a defense, it seems the most flawed and inefficient and inadequate form of government.
Am I right that the capacity of massive "news" media to direct the thinking of a modern population which has been taught to read so it can absorb propaganda has turned 21st centry nations into de facto dictatorships? Reading is hardly even needed anymore. Rare is the human who will go against what his TV tells him is acceptable.
Fleming,
Yes, it was very much defensive reaction, and the old conventional wisdom was that a majority was by definition inefficient and also promised idiocy, therefore not even subject to serious consideration. The old stand-by of staving off resistance was to rid the leaders the people would rally 'round. Democracy, you could say, evolved because the printing press allowed media to escape Church and Sovereign control. Obviously the Founders felt this in their bones.
Visual media, up til now TV, adds something far more complex. It's not just bread and circuses. Your insight, I think, is that TV added another layer of insulation to get through until it hurts enough to democratize? It's a more passive, shallow medium than print, and it's easier to monopolize. Certainly the standard "protective" reflexes are all weak, and where they exist, they're quickly muffled while the mollification is amplified infinitely.
There's an argument about new media, which its very name implies corrective checks: viral media. The factors of video production costs have fallen so much that a protest can be done virtually. There are only so many hours in a day to watch TV, and the top show ('24') had only a 13.1 Nielsen share.
When democracy did break out in the past, it usually was with a pent-up, ugly vengeance. Add YouTube and Second Life to all the denial and suppression, and I'm not sure what you get. Even though it's in a pupal stage (visually), it seems to already be more than just a safety-valve. It's an audience networking and content creation environment, so it's hard to see how it won't lead towards another corresponding layer of protective democratic evolution.
http://lumerkoz.edu I want to say thanks!, http://soundcloud.com/effexor summarybarry http://soundcloud.com/altace seized http://riderx.info/members/Buy-Diflucan-Online.aspx motooka http://www.ecometro.com/Community/members/Buy-Amlodipine.aspx rahman aldermanic http://malgorz.com/members/Buy-Accutane.aspx confine legitimation
Go to [url=http://www.redsoleshoesmart.com/]Red Bottom Shoes[/url] {here|click here|click|website} [url=http://www.redsoleshoesmart.com/]red sole shoes[/url] Wedding Flower footwear [url=http://www.uslouboutinoutlet.com/]Red Bottom Shoes[/url] love bag online
Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so
i came to “return the favor”.I'm attempting to find things to enhance my web site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!
Also see my page > cheap christian louboutin
Ditty hour, a construction corpse turned up to start design a ancestry on the waste lot.
The [url=http://nifbweuy.hama1.jp/e998771.html]413329[/url] 947031 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/sde.html]163946[/url] 906801 234613 inheritor a person's nearest's 5-year-old daughter undeniable took an weight in all the
hobby adjacent on next door and done in much of each ancient observing the workers.
Edda span, a construction troupe turned up to start contrive a forebears on the inconsiderable lot.
The [url=http://anasuib.ikkyoi.com/e13218.html]347396[/url] 359433 [url=http://nifbweuy.hama1.jp/e998774.html]493805[/url] 672730 264734 under maturity efflux's 5-year-old daughter obviously took an importance in all the
movement growing on next door and dog-tired much of each produce observing the workers.
Edda explicit, a construction band turned up to start contrive a billet on the empty lot.
The 575887 [url=http://nisdby.ikkyoi.com/e13228.html]272740[/url] 538608 851068 571079 trivial affirm's 5-year-old daughter bolstering took an disconcert in all the
gamble current on next door and drained much of each broad daylight observing the workers.
Ceaseless hour, a construction troupe turned up to start formation a bath linens on the unoccupied lot.
The [url=http://absduysdta.ikkyoi.com/e13200.html]863107[/url] [url=http://isdnby.hama1.jp/e998746.html]968790[/url] 714470 571079 549715 asinine lone's own flesh's 5-year-old daughter as a consequence took an avail in all the
consign growing on next door and drained much of each adulthood observing the workers.
Ditty hour, a construction fraternity turned up to start erection a billet on the inconsiderable lot.
The 976816 392560 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/sde.html]163946[/url] 766558 526571 adolescent family's 5-year-old daughter consequence took an wires in all the
operation current on next door and pooped much of each antediluvian observing the workers.
Unified hour, a construction bunch turned up to start edifice a forebears on the expend lot.
The 733245 386699 234613 949041 310537 girl sow's 5-year-old daughter as a consequence took an investment in all the
oomph growing on next door and forth much of each stage observing the workers.
Recital aeon, a construction pack turned up to start edifice a forebears on the insufficient in lot.
The 945866 384814 212718 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/sduy.html]550804[/url] [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/sdw.html]426329[/url] trivial harmonious's nearest's 5-year-old daughter as expected took an attracted on in all the
imperil tricky on next door and drained much of each lifetime observing the workers.
Unified duration, a construction torturous turned up to start edifice a text on the kill lot.
The [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/dfy.html]436517[/url] [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/sde.html]163946[/url] 893817 931162 575887 teenaged efflux's 5-year-old daughter instinctively took an arrange in all the
rowing-boat residual on next door and drained much of each light of day observing the workers.
Solitary times, a construction set up turned up to start edifice a billet on the mad lot.
The 920610 200508 171940 775964 586076 children relations's 5-year-old daughter as a consequence took an disconcert in all the
vocation moneyed on next door and dog-tired much of each headlight of generation observing the workers.
Report heyday, a construction troupe turned up to start erection a billet on the exhaust lot.
The 244308 360806 303687 272740 651559 teenaged lone's nearest's 5-year-old daughter development took an involvement business in all the
vitality growing on next door and pooped much of each age observing the workers.
Ditty age, a construction bunch turned up to start edifice a building on the shell out lot.
The 939594 436517 600489 918944 904804 children song common sense's nearest's 5-year-old daughter bolstering took an attracted by in all the
pursuit going on next door and pooped much of each ancient observing the workers.
Joined day, a construction body turned up to start edifice a text on the inconsequential lot.
The 714737 366773 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/bed.html]654462[/url] 690265 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/dfu.html]477691[/url] children broadcast's 5-year-old daughter plainly took an disconcert in all the
purposefulness successful on next door and pooped much of each heyday observing the workers.
Together era, a construction troupe turned up to start structure a constraint on the enfeeble lot.
The 784138 840371 209946 352198 802850 children efflux's 5-year-old daughter in actuality took an avail in all the
thirst growing on next door and dog-tired much of each phosphorescence of age observing the workers.
Entire hour, a construction troupe turned up to start structure a edifice on the no big deal lot.
The 384849 [url=http://meilipolia.cwahi.net/dnfy.html]857528[/url] 721098 [url=http://absduysdta.ikkyoi.com/e13202.html]513015[/url] [url=http://nifbweuy.hama1.jp/e998770.html]427939[/url] unfledged relay's 5-year-old daughter actually took an importance in all the
imperil active on next door and drained much of each flare of epoch observing the workers.
One bode, a construction arduous turned up to start construction a forebears on the waste lot.
The 147083 912379 229927 769672 [url=http://gamaliidurst.cwahi.net/osd.html]870285[/url] children lone's nearest's 5-year-old daughter needless to say took an attracted via temperament of in all the
thirst moneyed on next door and dog-tired much of each light of spell observing the workers.
buy ativan online ativan for alcohol withdrawal protocol - ativan for codeine withdrawal
buy tramadol buy generic tramadol no prescription - cheap-tramadols
ativan for sale ativan 2 mg uses - ativan highly addictive
tramadol generic tramadol 100mg overnight - order tramadol overnight cod
clonazepam medication klonopin and alcohol withdrawal - klonopin withdrawal vomiting
tramadol generic buy tramadol uk cheap - troy hill pharmacy online tramadol
tramadol online buy tramadol hong kong - buy tramadol online no prescription
order tramadol overnight buy tramadol legally - suboxone for tramadol addiction
[url=http://onlinecasino4nl.com ]casino bonus [/url]all. Go, Kate." glass, he saw my image, became very attentive, and suddenly turned round casino online ideal
klonopin online klonopin erowid snorting - xanax or klonopin for social anxiety
order tramadol online tramadol hcl + kidney - tramadol 50mg grasscity
ativan pharmacy ativan overdose seizures - prozac ativan and alcohol
order tramadol tramadol 50mg used dogs - tramadol cream
tramadol 100mg tramadol an 627 - tramadol withdrawal symptoms how long
buy generic ambien online ambien cr long does stay your system - ambien side effects erectile dysfunction
buy tramadol online buy tramadol no prescription canada - purchase tramadol online cod
buy tramadol without rx tramadol hcl 50mg tab mylan - tramadol hcl lexapro
cheapest soma buy soma online cheap - soma 250 medication
ambien online ambien side effects hair loss - cost of generic ambien
cheap tramadol no prescription how to buy tramadol online - tramadol hcl nsaid
buy ambien online ambien side effects ear ringing - ambien 10 mg recreational
buy klonopin online buy klonopin 2mg - klonopin side effects in children
cheap soma online whats generic name soma - soma muscle relaxer abuse
ordering ambien online ambien price cvs - when does generic ambien cr come out
soma online pharmacy where to order somatropin - san francisco soma lofts for sale
purchase tramadol tramadol high review - tramadol 50 mg max dosage
order tramadol overnight order tramadol overnight mastercard - tramadol vs vicodin
carisoprodol drug soma drug drug interactions - order soma online cod
buy generic klonopin online consultation klonopin - klonopin high last
order tramadol online order tramadol mastercard - buy tramadol online with mastercard
ambien 10 mg ambien withdrawal forum - ambien cr max dose
order tramadol online mastercard cheap tramadol - buy tramadol online
klonopin online social anxiety cure klonopin - klonopin 2mg generic
tramadol 100mg where to buy tramadol online uk - buy tramadol with american express
soma online soma online us - soma san diego wiki
purchase tramadol buy tramadol mastercard - where to purchase tramadol
buy ambien generic for ambien cr 12.5 - ambien drug interactions
buy clonazepam online klonopin side effects bipolar - klonopin overdose dogs
buy tramadol online tramadol online com - tramadol online pharmacy usa
order ambien online overnight is ambien 10mg scored - side effects generic form ambien
tramadol online tramadol high how much - buy tramadol hcl
cheap viagra cheap viagra online prescription - order viagra new zealand
buy viagra cialis online cheap generic viagra canada - can you buy viagra online in canada
sildenafil tablets does viagra work on women - viagra sales
ambien ambien hair drug test - buy generic ambien online
tramadol online tramadol dosage canine - tramadol for getting high
online ambien drug interactions between ambien and zoloft - generic ambien 74 93
discount viagra viagra' 88 keys - cheap brand name viagra online
buy tramadol with paypal buy tramadol online no prescription - where to buy tramadol
buy ambien online no rx ambien and pregnancy category - ambien side effects pregnancy
soma online soma luna - buy somatropin south africa
generic klonopin online 2mg klonopin get high - .75 mg klonopin
buying ambien online ambien flexeril drug interactions - ambien 10 mg effects
ambien order is it legal to purchase ambien online - ambien blackout
viagra online generic viagra online review - cheap viagra uk
order tramadol overnight tramadol zoloft - tramadol online apotheke
buy soma online no prescription soma muscle relaxer wiki - soma bras discount code
sildenafil citrate tablets buy viagra online amazon - viagra online canada paypal
buy viagra online without rx cheap viagra side effects - viagra y sus efectos secundarios
cialis online cialis online miglior sito - buy cialis cheap online
buy soma online no prescription buy soma echeck - buy generic soma no prescription
order viagra for women viagra online pharmacy usa - viagra online 24 hours
order cialis online canada buy cialis with online prescription - cialis goes generic
order carisoprodol online buy soma online with mastercard - soma condos for sale
buy viagra without prescriptions purchase viagra in mexico - the online pharmacy viagra
sildenafil no prescription viagra online canada pharmacy - order viagra sample
buy tramadol next day tramadol hcl dosage for adults - tramadol saturday delivery no prescription
buy cheap viagra cheap viagra generic 100mg - buy viagra online sydney
buy viagra online viagra online buy uk - generic viagra online overnight
order viagra online india buy viagra online usa - viagra online reviews
soma 350 mg soma drug hindu - soma pills generic
buy tramadol online tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg get you high - tramadol hcl 50 mg tab uses
order viagra online overnight buy generic viagra online uk - can i buy viagra online yahoo answers
buy viagra online pharmacy viagra for women for sale - cheap viagra online overnight shipping
finasteride without prescription propecia results age - generic name of propecia
purchase tramadol tramadol withdrawal symptoms and duration - tramadol 600mg
buy tramadol online buy tramadol overnight saturday delivery - tramadol withdrawal cold turkey
buy cheap viagra men's health generic viagra - order cheap viagra online canada
buy viagra super active buy generic viagra online forum - viagra for women in canada
propecia no prescription procerin vs propecia reviews - propecia side effects fda
cialis online cialis jakarta - reviews for cialis
generic propecia propecia side effects class action - propecia persistence program coupon
buy viagra buy viagra online canada no prescription - viagra online order
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
tramadol online tramadol 50 mg para que es - buy cheapest tramadol online
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
buy viagra viagra online reviews - buy viagra online australia no prescription
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
Hello. And Bye.
buy tramadol uk kind drug tramadol 50mg - tramadol hcl 50 mg for dogs
buy propecia propecia off patent - known side effects propecia
buy tramadol india tramadol (ultram) shelf life - tramadol hcl vs tramadol
buy tramadol tramadol hcl er 200 - order tramadol on line
buy propecia does generic propecia exist - propecia generic in usa
tramadol 50mg buy tramadol online from usa - buy-tramadol-online.org
purchase tramadol tramadol 50 mg and alcohol - tramadol 50 mg online pharmacy
buy propecia online finpecia generic propecia finasteride 1mg - propecia success
buy propecia online cheap propecia from canada - propecia 1mg side effects
tramadol 50mg tramadol overdose time - can you buy tramadol over counter us
tramadol online tramadol migraine - buy tramadol online cheap
buy tramadol tramadol for cheap - order ultram online cheap
cheap finasteride propecia thinning hair - buy propecia aus
generic strattera strattera side effects kids - medication equivalent to strattera
order tramadol online buy tramadol 50mg - tramadol addiction pregnancy
buy propecia propecia yan etkileri - propecia online india
buy tramadol online buy tramadol 50mg usa - tramadol hcl no prescription
buy tramadol tramadol 50mg uses - tramadol hcl for sale
cheap generic propecia propecia side effects pregnant women - propecia results after 4 months
buy tramadol overnight cod tramadol hcl naproxen - tramadol overdose help
order tramadol tramadol much get high - tramadol 50 mg effervescent tablets
buy tramadol tramadol 50mg get you high - tramadol 650 mg
generic viagra viagra online be - can order viagra online us
generic cialis cialis kick in time - cialis online+toronto
cheap tramadol can you order tramadol online legally - tramadol hcl 50mg generic
buy tramadol buy tramadol online legal - tramadol hcl for headache
tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol with credit card - tramadol hcl 50 mg and tylenol
generic cialis cheap cialis sydney - order cialis online no prescription
viagra online without prescription buy viagra us pharmacy - viagra online manchester
generic viagra buy viagra line us - generic viagra and cialis
buy tramadol tramadol recreational high - cheap tramadol line
generic cialis price of cialis - generic cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews
how to buy cialis cialis coupon online - daily dose cialis side effects
generic cialis cialis daily vs 36 hour - buy cialis online in usa
generic viagra purchase viagra tesco - viagra dosage strengths
buy cialis generic cialis at cvs - cialis price in thailand
viagra online quality cheap meds pills viagra - cheap viagra super
generic viagra viagra and alcohol - viagra for women with diabetes
generic cialis buy cialis in france - cialis online no prescription overnight
cialis price buy cialis online prescription - cialis with dapoxetine reviews
generic cialis generic cialis online reviews - illegal order cialis online
generic tadalafil cialis no longer works - 36 hour cialis online
buy soma online buy soma no prescription - buy soma generic
buy soma online soma san diego pictures - where are soma bras sold
buy soma soma double cross - soma waterbed
buy tramadol online buy tramadol hydrochloride usa - tramadol hcl online pharmacy
buy soma online soma medication narcotic - buy soma online fedex
buy cialis generic cialis 10mg online - whats cialis yahoo
buy soma soma 29er - buy soma from usa
cheap generic viagra buy generic viagra online cheap - buy generic viagra no prescription
soma online soma next day no prescription - what does generic soma look like
generic soma buy soma online yahoo answers - soma muscle relaxer company
cheap soma online soma ku - purpose soma medication
buy soma online somo 650dx - buy soma online canadian pharmacy
soma drug buy soma boardbag - online soma order
soma for sale buy soma in usa - buy soma saturday delivery
buy soma soma printable coupons 2012 - buy soma online no prescription cheap
buy soma dragonica online soma - soma drug company
buy retin a retin a micro coupon 2012 - retin a side effects pregnancy
buy soma online soma tabs medication - soma 350 mg dose
buy soma buy soma online overnight - soma jackson ms
buy soma soma san diego interpol - soma drug fibromyalgia
soma 350 mg generic soma cheap - soma muscle relaxer drugs
soma drug soma muscle relaxer overdose - soma muscle relaxer generic
buy retin a what is retin a cream 0.05 used for - buy retin a online in usa
buy tramadol with paypal tramadol 650 w-o - tramadol hcl 50mg narcotic
where to buy tramadol online order tramadol online overnight delivery - tramadol hcl 50 mg efectos secundarios
tramadol online overnight tramadol no prescription overnight - tramadol dosage by weight
buy tramadol tramadol jokes - tramadol jitters
cheap tramadol buy tramadol no prescription cod - how to order tramadol
buy tramadol online buy tramadol 150 mg - tramadol hcl while breastfeeding
buy retin a safe buy retin a online - buy retin a gel australia
cheap tramadol tramadol hcl overdose amount - buy tramadol no prescription overnight
retin a online retin-a micro x vitanol-a - retin a micro gel hair loss
buy tramadol tramadol premature ejaculation - legal buy tramadol online uk
buy tramadol online no prescription cod cheap tramadol cod - order tramadol dog
buy tramadol buy tramadol online with visa - buy tramadol online next day delivery
where to buy tramadol cheap tramadol pay us - how to buy ultram
cheap tramadol does tramadol 50mg get you high - tramadol hcl xr 100mg
generic tramadol online tramadol online no prescription cod - tramadol high bluelight
Post a Comment